Finding Home: An Exploration of South African Art Music through the Classical Saxophone and Collaborative Practice

Josie Mc Clure

This research project explores South African Art Music through collaborative practice and the classical saxophone. It begins by investigating the discourse surrounding South African Art Music through testimony collected from various conversations with South African composers, musicians and academics such as Dr Kevin Volans, Dr Antoni Schonken, Professor Hendrik Hofmeyr, Dr Cara Stacey and Arthur Feder. I began collecting the scores of South African saxophone compositions which led to the development of an online catalogue system to document these works -The South African Saxophone Catalogue. This catalogue forms the base - as well as the network - for how this research was developed. To further investigate the South African repertoire, I embarked on creative journeys with four South African composers through performer-composer collaboration. I decided to use this means of investigation as the relationship formed between myself and these composers shows a different level of engagement with this music, first-hand experience in the creation of this music as well as creating an open space for discourse. These collaborations were documented through reflections, audio and video recordings and are investigated in the form of case studies. The final artistic product was a concert featuring these new compositions in Cape Town, South Africa. The data collected was organised through an amalgamation of critical reflection and thematic analysis. Through this collective music-making, I discovered the variety in thought surrounding South African Art Music and paradoxically those who vigorously deny this term. I discovered the complexity both politically and socially that the term South African Art Music implies. In conjunction with my personal reflections, this exposition explores the ideas, opinions and art of individuals in various fields in the South African classical music scene who represent a variety of South African cultural backgrounds and generations.

Adegbite, A. 2001. The Present State of Development of African Art Music in Nigeria,‖ in African Art Music in Nigeria, ed. M. A. Omibiyi-Obidike. Nigeria: Stirling-Horden Publishers Ltd.

Agawu, K. 1992. Representing African Music. Critical Inquiry [Electronic], 18(2), 245–266. Available: https://www.jstor.org/stable/1343783 [2023, 19 November].

"Apartheid". n.d. Britannica [Electronic]. Available: https://www.britannica.com/topic/apartheid/Opposition-to-apartheid [2023, 22 November].

Borgdorff, H. 2012. Conflict of the Faculties Perspectives on Artistic Research and Academia. Leiden: Leiden University Press.

Broyles & Von Glahn, D. 2012. Art Music, in Grove Music Online. Oxford Music Online [Electronic]. Available: https://doi.org/10.1093/gmo/9781561592630.article.A2227279 [2023, 19 November].

Clarke, A. & Bautista, D. 2017. Critical Reflection on Arts-based action research. Canadian Journal of Action Research [Electronic], 18(1): 52-70. Available: https://journals.nipissingu.ca/index.php/cjar/article/view/321 [2023, 16 November].

Coessens, K. 2014. The Web of Artistic Practice: A Background for Experimentation. In D. Crispin & B. Gilmore (Eds.), Artistic Experimentation in Music: An Anthology (pp. 69–81). Leuven University Press.

Deppe, L, M. 2012. South African Music in Transition: A Flutist‘s Perspective. Unpublished doctoral thesis: University of Toronto

Davies, R. 2007. Rebuilding the Future or Revisiting the Past? Post-Apartheid Afrikaner Politics. Trading Africa’s Future [Electronic], 34(112): 353-370. Available: https://www.jstor.org/stable/20406402 [2023, 20 October].

Ewing, M. H. 2016. Perspectives of the interaction between composer, student performer, and music educator: commissioned works in selected school ensembles. Published doctoral dissertation. Boston University: ProQuest.

Fanning, D. 1995. ‘Introduction. Talking about eggs: musicology and Shostakovich’, in D. Fanning (ed.) Shostakovich Studies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press (Cambridge Composer Studies), pp. 1–16.

Foss, L. 1963. The Changing Composer-Performer Relationship: A Monologue and a Dialogue. Perspectives of New Music [Electronic], 1(2): 45-53. Available: https://www.jstor.org/stable/832102 [2023, 16 November].

Hannula, M., Suoranta, J., & Vaden, T. 2005. Artistic Research- Theories Methods and Practices.
Academy of Fine Arts. Gothenburg: Artmonitor.

John-Steiner., V. 2000. Creative Collaboration. Oxford University Press

Ligeti, L. 2014. "Juilliard concert review". NewMusicSA Bulletin. 13: 9–10.

Loveday, C.C. 2009. Collusion and collision: a composition portfolio focusing on straight saxophone, and a thesis. Doctoral Dissertation.

Mc Clure, J. 2023. South African Saxophone Compositions: Exploring the process of creating new music for saxophone through the lens of artistic research and performer-composer collaboration. Unpublished master’s thesis. Stellenbosch: Stellenbosch University.

Muller, S. (2022) ‘Michael Blake’s String Quartets And The Idea Of African Art Music’, Tempo, 76(300), pp. 6–17. doi:10.1017/S0040298221000887.

Roche, H. 2011. Dialogue and Collaboration in the Creation of New Works for Clarinet. Unpublished Doctoral thesis. Huddersfield: University of Huddersfield [Online]. Available: http://eprints.hud.ac.uk/id/eprint/17512/ [2023, 22 November].

Sall, T. L. 2018. The Rainbow Myth: Dreaming of a Post-racial South African Society. Institute for Global Dialogue [Electronic]. Available: http://www.jstor.com/stable/resrep19352 [2023, 20 November].

Smit, N. 2014. Creating new music for horn through collaborative practice. Unpublished master's thesis. Stellenbosch: Stellenbosch University [Online]. Available: http://scholar.sun.ac.za/handle/10019.1/95843 [2023, 16 November].

Stolp. M. 2012. Contemporary Performance Practice of Art Music in South Africa: A Practice-based Research Enquiry. Doctoral Dissertation. Stellenbosch University.

Taylor, T. D. 1995. When we Think About Music and Politics: The Case of Kevin Volans. Perspectives of New Music [Electronic], 33 (1): 504-536. Available: https://www.jstor.org/stable/833716 [2023, 18 October].

Personal Communication

Asman, C. 2024. South African Art Music [email] to J. McClure, 15 January.

Hofmeyr, H. 2024. South African Art Music [email] to J. McClure, 22 January.

Schonken, A. 2024. South African Art Music [email] to J. McClure, 12 January.

Stacey, C. 2024. South African Art Music [email] to J. McClure, 15 January.

Volans, K. 2024. South African Art Music [email] to J. McClure, 19 January.

Chen, A. X. 2024. Collaboration [email] to J. McClure, 9 February.

Chen, A. X. 2023. Personal interview. 20 February, The Hague. [Recording in possession of author].

Chen, A. X. 2023. Personal interview. 2 March, The Hague. [Recording in possession of author].

Chen, A. X. 2023. Personal interview. 15 March, The Hague. [Recording in possession of author].

Chen, A. X. Personal communication, [WhatsApp]. 20 March 2023.

Chen, A. X. 2023. Personal interview. 4 April, The Hague. [Recording in possession of author].

Chen, A. X. Personal communication, [WhatsApp]. 26 April 2023.

Chen, A. X. 2023. Personal interview. 5 May, The Hague. [Recording in possession of author].

Chen, A. X. 2023. Personal interview. 8 January, The Hague. [Recording in possession of author].

Chen, A. X. 2024. Personal interview . 20 February, The Hague. [Recording in possession of author].

Chen, A. X. Personal communication, [WhatsApp]. 27 February 2024.

Dalton, O. 2023. Personal interview. 8 March, The Hague. [Recording in possession of author].

Dalton O. Personal Communication, [WhatsApp]. 25 April 2021.

Feder, A. 2021. Personal interview. 20 August, Stellenbosch. [Recording in possession of author].
Feder, A. 2021. Personal interview. 23 April, Stellenbosch. [Recording in possession of author].
Feder, A. 2022. Personal interview. 6 June, Stellenbosch. [Recording in possession of author].
Feder, A. 2022. Three Nocturnes from Africa [email] to J. Mc Clure, 30 March.
Feder, A. Personal Communication, [WhatsApp]. 25 April 2021.
Feder, A. Personal Communication, [WhatsApp]. 25 October 2021.
Feder, A. Personal Communication, [WhatsApp]. 19 July 2023.

Feder, A. Personal Communication, [WhatsApp]. 27 February 2024.

Loveday C, 2022. Personal interview. 18 June, Stellenbosch. [Recording in possession of author].

Loveday, C. 2021. 8 Minute Saxophone [email] to J. Mc Clure, 8 December.

Loveday, C. 2021. Personal interview. 26 May, Stellenbosch. [Recording in possession of author].
Loveday, C. 2021. Personal interview. 6 September, Stellenbosch. [Recording in possession of author].
Loveday, C. 2023. Personal interview. 20 July 2023, St. Francis Bay. [Recording in possession of author].

Loveday, C. 2024. 8 Minute Saxophone [email] to J. Mc Clure, 28 February.

Informal conversation with Dr Andile Khumalo, 26 July 2023.

Tip

Tip