In Search of the Public: Exploring Contemporary Performance Practices of Classical Music in the Netherlands

Julia Friederike Pank

Classical music performance is widely associated with grand concert halls and an elitist audience and has increasingly been critiqued for not maintaining contact with the wider public. Some even speak of a “crisis of classical music,” (Freeman 2014; Behrman 2009; Lurvink 2006) as it becomes more challenging to raise sufficient funds, and, due to declining subsidies, to sustain a visiting public. Recently, the art sector (not only) in the Netherlands has gathered its energies for profound restructuring and change. Difficult conditions contrast with the still widely held image of the Netherlands as a thriving innovative environment for the arts, known for its bustling ensemble culture of around 1000 diverse groups ranging from small chamber music ensembles to symphony orchestras (beroepkunstenaar.nl; Cobussen 2000). Is live classical music no longer relevant in a fast-paced, technologically oriented contemporary society? What and who determines its relevance? And which strategies do musicians generate in order to counter such unfavorable developments? In this research project, drawing upon several academic and artistic methods, a number of case studies, constituting potential alternatives to the traditional concert practice, has been investigated. These include bringing music to new and transformed locations, increasing audience participation, or turning the performance into a multi-sensorial experience. What implications do such practices have for the audience-performer relationship? And how do alternative performance practices affect our understanding of “classical music”? This article can be seen as a “brief history of what is now changing” (Gumbrecht 2004: 21) in the world of classical music in the Netherlands, focusing on specific examples that attempt to innovate the sector, thereby giving some insight as to its strengths and weaknesses.

Prelude

Exposition

Exploration

Reflection

Recapitulation

References

REFERENCES

Becker, Howard S. (1976). “Art Worlds and Social Types.” American Behavioral Scientist 19/6: 703-719.

Behrman, Simon (2009). “From Revolution to Irrelevance: How Classical Music Lost Its Audience.” International Socialism 121.

Bourdieu, Pierre (1983). “The Field of Cultural Production or: The Economic World Reversed.” Poetics 12: 311-356.

Brook, Peter (1968). The Empty Space. London: Penguin Classics.

Bussemaker, Jet (2015). “Ruimte Voor Cultuur: Uitgangspunten Cultuurbeleid 2017-2020.” Den Haag: Ministerie voor Onderwijs, Cultuur en Wetenschap.

Christenhusz, Joep (2016). Componisten van Babel. Arnhem: ArtEZ Press.

De Nationale Opera. “And You Must Suffer – Johannespassie.” Amsterdam: De Nationale Opera.

Dreyfus, Laurence (2007). “Beyond the Interpretation of Music.” Dutch Journal of Music Theory 12/3: 253-272.

Freeman, Robert (2014). The Crisis of Classical Music in America: Lessons Learned From a Life in the Education of Musicians. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.

Gumbrecht, Hans-Ulrich (2003). The Production of Presence – What Meaning Cannot Convey. Redwood City: Stanford University Press.

Hamel, Micha (2016). Speelruimte voor Klassieke Muziek in de 21ste Eeuw. Rotterdam: Codarts.

Harris, Geraldine (1999). Staging Femininities: Performance and Performativity. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

Kramer, Lawrence (2007). Why Classical Music Still Matters. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Lurvink, Peter (2006). “Over het Modernisme en de Crisis van de Klassieke Muziek.” Dutch Journal of Music Theory 11/1: 36-48.

Marlet, Gerard (2010). “Kunstsubsidies Onder Druk.” NOVA. Nijmegen: VOC Uitgevers.

Ministry of Education, Culture, and Science (2006). “Cultural Policy in the Netherlands.” Boekmanstudies. Amsterdam: Boekman Stichting.

Ricciotti Ensemble. “Missie.” Amsterdam: Riciotti.

LUDWIGlive. “Over Ludwig.” Amsterdam: LUDWIG.

Perec, Georges (1997). Species of Spaces and Other Pieces. London: Penguin Classics.

Rubinoff, Kailan R (2011). “Cracking The Dutch Early Music Movement: The Repercussions of the 1969 Notenkrakersactie.” Twentieth-Century Music 6/1: 3-22.

Rusch, Loes (2011). “Common Ground: 1970s Improvised Music as Part of a Cross-Genre Dutch Ensemble Culture.” Jazz Research Journal 5/1-2: 123-141.

Small, Christopher (1998). Musicking. The Meanings of Performance and Listening. Middletown: Wesleyan University Press.

Stevenson, John (1995). “The Fourth Wall and The Third Space.” New Paltz: Centre for Playback Theatre.

Taylor, Cintia (2011). “Dutch Government to Slash Culture Subsidies.” Bonn: Deutsche Welle.

Van den Berg, Simon (2011). “Dutch Arts Cuts Explained.” Amsterdam: Simber.

Van Eikels, Kai, and Bettina Brandl-Risi (2011). “What There Will Be Instead Of An Audience.” Performance Research 16/3: 19-34. London: Taylor and Francis Group.

IN SEARCH OF THE PUBLIC.

EXPLORING CONTEMPORARY PERFORMANCE PRACTICES

OF CLASSICAL MUSIC IN THE NETHERLANDS

Julia Friederike Pank

Research Project “(Re)positioning Modern Concert Music in Contemporary Society”

Research Traineeship Program 2017

Academy of Creative and Performing Arts, Leiden University, the Netherlands

Tip

Tip